‘Unreasonable to consider sending money to prisons as a crime’

  • actual
  • 15:59 31 March 2024
  • |
img

ISTANBUL - IHD Co-Chair Eren Keskin stated that the arrest of 75-year-old Hatice Yıldız for sending money to her daughter and her friend in prison has no basis in law and described the situation as "irrational".

The small amounts of money that families deposit to their relatives who are prisoned in prisons for political reasons to meet their needs have become a threat for a while because they are considered within the scope of the "Law on prevention of financing of terrorism".
 
Due to this law, many relatives of prisoners faced investigation, detention and arrest for sending money to prisons. Finally, 75-year-old Hatice Yıldız, living in Esenyurt, Istanbul, was tried on the charge of "financing a terrorist organization" for sending money to her daughter and her daughter's cellmate in prison.
 
Yıldız, whose prison sentence of 4 years and 2 months given by the Istanbul 14th High Criminal Court was approved by the Court of Appeal, was recently arrested and put in Bakırköy Women's Closed Prison, despite her advanced age and many health problems such as high blood pressure, eye, lumbar herniation and spinal curvature. .
 
Speaking to MA, Human Rights Association (IHD) Co-Chair Eren Keskin said that "enemy law" is applied to 75-year-old Yıldız, who was arrested for sending money to her daughter.
 
Stating that the "Law on prevention of financing of terrorism" has been signed by many states and one of these states is Turkey, Keskin said that when they look at the example of Hatice Yıldız, the law is used completely outside its intended purpose. Keskin stated that, as a lawyer, she found the situation "tragicomical and irrational".
 
'THERE IS NO ILLEGAL ACTION'
 
Keskin emphasized that the sending of money by relatives of prisoners to any prisoner in prisons has nothing to do with the law in question and said: “In order to finance terrorism, an illegal action must occur. Here, when relatives of prisoners send money, they do so with the ID card given to them by the state and it is deposited in the administration of the prisons. In other words, when we look at the Hatice Yıldız incident, that is not illegal is punished illegally. That's why this is so irrational. This situation actually shows how deplorable the situation the judiciary is in."
 
'REFLECTED AS IF IT IS A HIDDEN ACTIVITY'
 
Reminding that prisoners in prisons have to buy all their needs from the canteen, Keskin said: “From their most basic needs to hygiene and white goods, they buy them from the canteens and therefore they buy them from the prison administration. That's why people in prisons need money. They need to meet these needs. Naturally, these people's acquaintances and relatives deposit money. It is irrational to portray this as if it were a secret activity. That's why Hatice Yıldız is in prison.”
 
Keskin shared that Yıldız, a patient with hypertension and dementia whom she visited in prison, was not in good health and she often fainted.
 
Keskin said that the prison administration did not even give her the medicines that the doctors gave her for her forgetfulness and said: “She is very sad because she has an 85-year-old paralyzed husband at home. Her thoughts are constantly on her paralyzed husband and her daughter who is imprisoned in prison. This situation applied to her can only be defined by enemy law."
 
'THE PURPOSE IS TO ISOLATE PRISONS'
 
Stating that the application of the law in this way causes oppression, Keskin continued her words as follows: “There was no such practice in the past, they introduced it recently. While the state says to the outside, ‘Look, I am implementing this law’ on the other hand, it wants to implement a new policy of fear and intimidation. So everything we do is seen as a crime. Our thoughts, speech and writing are considered crimes. If you are an oppositionist, especially if you do not have the basic lines of the official ideology on the Kurdish issue, you are under judicial control outside, even if you are not in prison. Currently, everyone in the country is living as hostage. Every step we take is controlled. Therefore, one of the reasons why they implemented that law in this way is to increase these policies of fear and isolate prisons.”
 
Keskin said: “People are really lonely in prison. Many political prisoners are transferred to prisons far away from where their families are located. You cannot reach the guardian of many of them, some do not even know that they have a guardian. We know mostly what is happening in nearby prisons. IHD is trying to reach all prisons, but not everyone's family knows how to reach institutions like IHD. The state wants to accuse them of being 'terrorist' by considering any statement or action made about the prisoners as a 'terrorist' activity. There is nothing that can be explained legally about this. There is no such thing in any article of the Constitution.”
 
ISOLATION WITHIN ISOLATION
 
Keskin also conveyed the rights violations suffered by DEM Party Esenyurt District Co-chair Bahar Karataş, whom she visited in Bakırköy Women's Closed Prison. Keskin said: "Karataş's wards were frequently searched and these searches had now reached the level of harassment. Soldiers and man guards entered the wards and together with the woman guards, searched the wards and distributed all the belongings. We receive similar news from many prisons. When I went to prison yesterday, an incident happened right before my eyes. During the meeting, the guards asked Bahar Karataş to take off her shoes. When she did not take off her shoes, the guard tried to forcefully remove the shoes from the prisoner's feet with her own feet. This is a violation of the rights of both prisoners and lawyers. Because this approach is the product of an understanding that also sees the defense as guilty. Here, the lawyer is also accused along with the prisoner. I think this is an isolation within an isolation, but political prisoners are resisting it."
 
MA / Esra Solin Dal
 

View More Articles

09/04/2025
14:23 DEM Party Imrali Delegation to meet Erdoğan tomorrow
13:58 Attacks continue despite ceasefire
13:10 Journalists sued for 'not being a journalist'
12:44 Berkin Elvan's mother and father sentenced to prison
12:41 Up to 15 years imprisonment demand against Fırat Epözdemir
12:06 Abdullah Öcalan: I keep my hope, I will take the process to the end
09:49 Visit ban to prisoners due to refusing mouth search
09:44 At least 14 thousand 478 people arrested in last 3 months
09:41 Families of detained YBŞ members call for solidarity
09:40 Ferhat Kurtay's brother: If the call is upheld, the state will be forced to take steps
08/04/2025
15:47 Prisoners in Iran: Increase in executions
13:53 Women tell strip search denied by Minister
12:27 Mahir Polat to refer to hospital again
12:05 We will lead the socialisation of the call say HDK youth
11:31 Lawyers apply to go to İmralı
11:14 Nobel laureate Nargis Mohammadi calls struggle to stop executions
09:10 Trustee expelled many children from day-care centres
09:09 Ministry refuse to implement red notice decision due to 'missing documents'
07/04/2025
16:21 Attack on Baloch activists in Pakistan
16:02 Qoser's call to the state: Take practical steps
15:13 Visit to Binevs Altay's condolence: Solution and attack do not go together
14:45 Israel targets journalists' tent
14:41 Mahir Polat taken back to prison
13:40 Attack against Gaza continues: 44 dead
13:18 'Strip search' explanation from Minister: It is out of question in our country
12:28 Boycott continues at YTU
11:53 Pakhshan Azizi's retrial request rejected for second time
11:26 Prisoner having a heart attack sent to ward under pretext of 'blood pressure'
10:57 Öcalan has to be free, there could be no process without him says Kariane Westrheim
10:50 Mahsum Korkmaz's brother: We want an honourable peace
10:43 31 years in prison: Call accepted wholeheartedly in prison
06/04/2025
15:04 Murdered Journalists Day: 15 journalists murdered in the last 5 years
13:50 JINNEWS: 24 women murdered in March
13:36 Women in Xelfetî: We want to celebrate April 4th with Öcalan
10:49 Mother lost 2 children: Peace possible through dialogue
10:07 Çiftçi, 84, was on the road to Amara with his red scarf
09:24 First footage from MA: Hundreds of skulls and bones found under the church
04/04/2025
12:05 Kurd Archive: 30 years of treasure unravelling
12:03 4 April Festival continues on 2nd day
12:02 'Birth of Abdullah Öcalan is rebirth of Kurds'
11:03 Photojournalist: We were detained due to showing the violence
11:01 'Şervano' song found dangerous, artist penalised
03/04/2025
22:19 Letter from Abdullah Öcalan to Youth
17:15 Amara marchers march to Xelfetî despite attacks
14:40 Amnesty International: Massacres of Alawite civilians must be investigated as war crimes
14:33 Youth march on its 3rd day: 33 'dream travellers' commemorated
13:58 DFG March report: 21 journalists detained, 8 arrested
13:03 4 April Festival enthusiasm in Xelfeti
12:09 At least 56 Baloch massacred in Iran in 3 months
11:30 Kurds and their friends in Europe prepare to 4 April