ECtHR Lawyer: Demirtaş and Kavala decision must be implemented

  • actual
  • 10:33 24 February 2020
  • |
img

URFA – The former lawyer of the ECtHR Editorial Office, Ümit Kılınç, drew attention to the need to implement the decisions made on Selahattin Demirtaş and Osman Kavala.

 
Former Editor in Chief lawyer of European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) Ümit Kılınç, stated that not implementing the decision on Selahattin Demirtaş and Osman Kava is a violation of the Article 18 of European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR).
 
Pointing out that the applicants were deprived of their liberty in both cases, Kılınç said, "According to my opinion, both should be released immediately according to Article 46." 
 
DEMİRTAŞ IS HELD ON POLITICAL REASONS
 
Kılınç pointing out that ECtHR decided that the 3rd subclause of the 5th article and the 18th article of European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) is violated in Demirtaş case, said: "The violation decision here means: Selahattin Demirtaş is under arrest for political reasons rather than legal reasons. The Human Rights Court decided to release the applicant based on article 46 of the contract. But that decision was not implemented. Afterwards, both the applicant and the government decided that the case should be sent to the grand chamber.It is not very healthy to talk about this case at the moment because the case is currently pending. The trial was held, but the decision has not been made. Therefore, the decision made by the grand chamber after this stage is not a valid decision. ecause the case is currently pending before the grand chamber."
 
Kılınç stated that in Osman Kavala's case ECtHR ruled that the 5/1 C article of the Humans' Rights Convention was violated and that there was no reasonable suspicion to deprive the applicant's liberty. Kılınç said: "This means that there is nothing valid to deprive the applicant of his liberty. Along with this, ECtHR decided that Article 18 was violated as well. These two cases are very important for Turkey. Because this is the first time Turkey is accused of violation Article 18.  In fact, the Turkish authorities deprive the applicants of their liberty in terms of abuse of the right. In the Kavala and Demirtaş cases, the court demanded that the applicants be released."
 
'KAVALA MUST HAVE BEEN RELEASED'
 
Kılınç also said the following regarding the execution of the decision on Kavala: "The real question here is that whether they should execute the decision immediately or wait 3 months for the decision to be finalized? The government's argument in this regard is to wait 3 months. If the case does not go to the grand chamber  within 3 months, it is finalized in this way and the decision made by the Human Rights Court becomes binding. According to Article 46, the execution of a decision made by the Court of Human Rights belongs to the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe. But recently, the ECtHR has put itself in the place of the committee and says how the decision should be executed. The ECtHR directly says how the violation decision will be enforced. So it is said that the person should be released immediately.Therefore, it is not necessary to wait 3 months for the applicant's case. Because what does the 3-month period mean? After the case is finalized, he will go to the Committee of Ministers for execution. In my opinion, if the person is requested to be released immediately according to the 46th article, that person should be released immediately."
 
POLITICAL PRESSURE
 
Kılınç, explaining what should be done next, said: "The file has not been sent to the Committee of Ministers yet. Because the 3 month period has not expired.Therefore, I do not think that if a letter is written to the Committee of Ministers, there will be a result at this stage. But the Council of Europe can apply pressure on Turkey. Countries comply when the Human Rights Court makes a decision. But Kavala and Demirtaş were not released. This is not usual. So there is a case law in this regard. A solution can be found when the applicant or representatives correspond with the court and report the situation to the General Secretariat of the Council of Europe."
 
 
 

View More Articles

14/05/2020
13:41 Complaint from 72 prisons to CISST
13:39 Karadağ: Government wants to create its own bar associations
13:38 Police violence against child aged 8 in Bismil
13:36 Osmanağaoğlu: Paramilitary forces are mobilized
13:31 Explosion in Efrin
09:44 Covid-19: Death toll rises to 3,952 in Turkey
09:43 Criminal complaint against destruction of graves
09:42 HDK Women's Assembly warns: We will not allow the abuse amnesty
13/05/2020
15:34 HDP: New Law on Execution cleared the way for Soma defendants
15:29 Kurdish politician Mahmut Alınak released
13:42 Dean, came up with his sexist discourse, resigned
13:41 KESK: We will call them to account for Soma sooner or later
13:41 The price of every soul in Soma is only 6 days in prison
13:40 Seriously sick prisoner Kaya taken into Intensive Care
13:40 Writer Robar: Let's keep alive the language, the spirit and the body
10:47 Günay: Government provides the police with an armour of impunity
09:31 Historic Hasankeyf sinks in water and garbage
09:30 TJA activist Paçal loses her life
09:29 Court releases the people detained in Gökçek's funeral
09:24 53 more people die of coronavirus in Turkey
09:20 ECHR rejects Turkey's Kavada objection
12/05/2020
16:58 Another doctor lost his life due to COVID-19
16:53 Call from HDP: Do not go to shopping-malls
16:52 Sancar answers back to Akşener
16:52 Buldan: They must apologize
11:35 Call from Grup Yorum
11:34 Arson of the church on parliamentary agenda
11:05 Quarantine removed after 33 days
11:05 Erdoğan announces 4 day curfew
10:09 Death toll in Turkey increases to 3 thousand 841
11/05/2020
17:26 TJA activist Biçimli lost her life
16:53 Mother of Şerzan Kurt: I thought my son would be the last one
13:47 TurkStat: Unemployment rate stood at 13.6 percent in february
13:15 Başaran: An independent health committee should visit İmralı
13:15 HDK: Attacks against cemeteries are attacks against the human values
13:14 'The oppressed will make the world a better place by solidarity'
11:34 Lawyers call for 'joint struggle'
11:33 Goes beyond the limits of forbearance
09:30 Attempted attack on İbrahim Gökçek's grave
08:32 Women visits grave of Taybet İnan on Mother's Day
08:31 Turkey: Death toll from coronavirus rises to 3,786
10/05/2020
16:27 It is inexplicable what happened in death fast resistor Gökçek's funeral
16:23 On the streets again after 50 days
13:36 The Court of Cassation Attorney General asked for the reversal of penalty decision
13:21 The family of the child exposed to police violence talked
13:08 Sancar spoke with the family of the child chased by the armed police
12:54 Prisoners in hunger strike threatened with death
12:35 HDP Women'sAssembly: Keeping guard on graves deemed proper for Kurdish mothers
09:02 New statement from the District Governorate of Nusaybin
08:54 TMMOB City Planners Chamber: We stand with the people of Sur