Öcalan’s lawyer: Legal isolation combined with physical isolation in İmralı

img
ANKARA - Lawyer Faik Özgür who filed an appeal with a request of immediate action to the Constitutional Court of Turkey due to not being able to communicate with and hear news from the imprisoned PKK leader Abdullah Öcalan said, "the communication with Öcalan is prevented," and called for the inhuman isolation conditions in İmralı Prison to be terminated, especially demanding the ban on the communication rights of Öcalan to be lifted.
 
The lawyers from Asrın Law Bureau who have been defending the Kurdistan Workers' Party (PKK) leader Abdullah Öcalan, Ömer Hayri Konar, Hamili Yıldırım and Veysi Aktaş imprisoned in İmralı Type F Hıgh Security Prison filed an application to the Constitutional Court (AYM) on June 19.
 
After an eight-year ban on lawyer-client meeting, Öcalan was allowed to be visited by his lawyers Rezan Sarıca and Nevroz Uysal on May 2, May 22, June 12, June 18 and Aug. 7 in 2019, but his lawyers haven’t been receiving any responses to the 86 applications they filed to visit Öcalan ever since. Öcalan could use his telephone right for the first time on April 27 due to the COVID-19 pandemic, but after that no news have been heard from neither Öcalan nor other 3 prisoners on the island.
 
Lawyer Faik Özgür Erol from Asrın Law Bureau talked to Mezopotamya Agency (MA) regarding the health conditions and the unjust applications his clients face in İmralı Island Prison. 
 
ISLAND CLIMATE AND 21 YEARS OF ISOLATION: 'RISK ON ÖCALAN'S HEALTH'
 
Emphasizing that Öcalan has chronic diseases Erol said, "He has chronic upper respiratory tract disease. We also know that he had had a small operation in İmralı due to the oil glands in his head in the recent years. He had a problem with his eyes that we could observe in our meetings.There are many risks in terms of health the İmralı system brings along. One should definitely take it into consideration that there are some results of being exposed to the humidity of the island for such a long time. The island environment has been an effective ground for some of the diseases Öcalan had to rather progress. In the past, we have witnessed that the respiratory disease has progressed rapidly under the island conditions causing severe respiratory problems that keeps them sleepless at night, especially in the case of Mr. Öcalan. The ages, the time spent in prison and the chronic diseases of Öcalan and his three friends should also be taken into account as distinct factors as a whole when considering these conditions. In case of Öcalan, what is harder than the 20 years of island climate is the isolation of the 21-years-of imprisonment. Risks during the COVID-19 pandemic have just raised the threads on Öcalan's health, which are already structural threads in İmralı Prison. Right at the beginning of the pandemic process, we applied to all related institutions and asked a series of questions regarding the level of measures in İmralı, whether it was possible to access protective, disinfecting, hygienic materials, whether coronavirus tests were conducted or not. The most important reason that we raised such questions is the isolation. We had no chance to visit him like in the other prisons or at least to be informed by him over a phone call. The legal process that started with this process that we had no answer back has prepared our Constitutional Court application."
 
'DISCIPLINARY TRIALS AS SECRET LEGAL PRACTICES HIDDEN FROM LAWYERS'
 
Erol also mentioned the arbitrary disciplinary sanctions in İmralı, which are repeatedly given to Öcalan and other 3 prisoners the grounds of which they have been given no information especially for the last 2.5 years saying, "We have no idea on what grounds the disciplinary penalties have been given for the last 2.5 years! Because they never show us the lawyers the files regarding those penalties, they even hide some of the disciplinary penalties from us. We have seen the political sovereigns have neglected the law, but in case of İmralı they literally abduct the law trying to hide disciplinary trials, which they conduct almost discretely for 2.5 years, they try to hide a legal process from the lawyers. This is such a weird situation. They try to combine legal isolation with the physical isolation in İmralı isolation system. So the disciplinary trials inside the İmralı Prison to have turned into secret trial practices are the most important ground for our application to Constitutional Court."
 
HEAVY ISOLATION, NON-COMMUNICATION AND PANDEMIC
 
Erol emphasizes an issue that he thinks the national and international public should be very carefully paying attention: "In the past, while the practices such as restrictions on visit, recording the lawyer-client interviews were imposed in İmralı, but it was not legal. However, such impositions to be applied 'only in İmralı' led the democratic public to ignore these violations of rights. Since 2016, we have seen that the restrictions in İmralı have been imposed in all other prisons as well as to the whole society, as these have also become legalized and justified. That is a risk that we should draw attention. Our application to Constitutional Court includes the violations both by the disciplinary trials inside the İmralı Prison and by the non-examinable conditions of the İmralı system. The motion for injunction we filed expresses an urgent demand for the removal of conditions involving ill-treatment caused by heavy isolation and non-communication combined with pandemic conditions. Although our application focuses on a specific conditions which requires immediate release, we cannot ignore the fact that İmralı isolation has been increasingly imposed for 20 years and Mr. Öcalan was held in solitary confinement in İmralı for more than 10 years which was declared as a violation of the article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights regarding the 'torture and maltreatment'. 
 
'SOLITARY CONFINEMENT FOR 23 HOURS A DAY'
 
Erol tells more about the isolation system in İmralı, imposed not just on Öcalan, but also on the other prisoner which were taken to İmralı after him: "After that 5 other prisoners have been taken to İmralı, but they were forced to spent the 23 hours of the day in solitary confinement, as they were allowed to see each other 1 hour a day, 5 times a week. This was exactly the same restriction imposed on the prisoners taken to İmralı in 2015. Now there are 3 prisoners in İmralı other than Mr. Öcalan and they are able to see each other 1 hour a day, 5 days a week. In addition to this isolation inside the prison, a strict isolation regarding the communication with the outside have begun to be applied since 2015. Between July 2011-May 2019 no lawyer or family visit was allowed.  Weekly phone call right has never been allowed in İmralı before anyway. After four lawyers were allowed to visit Mr Öcalan in 2019, the visits have been interrupted as of August 2019 all of a sudden again. During the pandemic Ministry of Justice has increased the weekly telephone right of the prisoners to twice a week, which was once a week before the pandemic. We also applied for this right to be used in İmralı, but only on April 27, they have allowed only one phone call and that's all. 
 
'THE CONTINUOUS BAN ON COMMUNICATION SHOULD IMMEDIATELY BE LIFTED'
 
Referring to the "systematic state of non-communication" in İmralı Prison Erol explains the nature of their application to the Constitutional Court of Turkey: "Therefore we can talk about a systematic state of non-communication forced in İmralı which has been extended over rather a long period of time. This state of non-communication of long years has broken İmralı off civil and legal inspection opportunities and when it combined with pandemic conditions, it increased the level of anxiety and suffering. When all this is combined, we cannot only and simply detect a violation of the communication right, but also an inhuman maltreatment caused by an indefinite and systematic ban on communication. This is the content of our request for action in its most abstract form. We demand from the Constitutional Court to immediately end the current inhuman condition of continuous state of non-communication in İmralı Prison. The Constitutional Court is required to rule the decision on such an application 'immediately' as defined by the law.  If the Constitutional Court keeps its silence, we will carry our application to the European Court of Human Rights."
 
MA / Berivan Altan
 

View More Articles

30/11/2020
11:39 1 year 6 months 22 days prison sentence for Journalist Öztekin
11:22 Youth discusses isolation: The key to democracy is in İmralı
10:43 The hypocrisy of the ECtHR: Execution was replaced with isolation
10:42 KNK Co-chair: People of Bashur do not want inner conflict
28/11/2020
13:21 Erdoğan speaks of 'judicial reform': 415 citizens detained
11:01 Police raid on the homes of IHD and MEBYA-DER executives
10:49 Kozluk Co-Mayor detained
10:43 Z.N, raped at the removal center, transferred to guest house
10:43 Lawyers detained in Bursa, released
10:42 'Prisoners from Rojava are being punished twice'
27/11/2020
15:01 Scores detained in multiple cities
13:44 Families submit application to visit İmralı
13:44 Night raid on HDP building in Van
13:43 Ehmed: An agreement to rebuild Shengal is needed
10:48 Our reporter Karataş put in a cell
10:19 Prosecutor investigated if the 24 civillians who were killed 5 years ago had ties with 'the organization'
10:19 Our reporter Hakan Yalçın detained
26/11/2020
17:28 Our reporter Karataş arrested
16:11 ECtHR’s scandalous verdict on HDP: HDP does not have victim status
14:12 Our reporter Karataş is accused of news interviews
14:11 Police raided HDK building while no one was there, seized digital materials
14:11 Leyla Öztürk was killed with a state issued gun
14:10 Seeing their clients in prison considered a crime
14:08 Attorneys of Öcalan submits new application to visit İmralı
12:44 Heavy deployment of troops continues in Shengal
12:34 Journalist Metina: They asked if I was a member of Kurdish Writers Association
12:33 Mother who lost her daughter in Shengal Massacre: We must stand against war
10:31 Scores detain in operation in İstanbul
10:17 Êzidî intellectuals: Peshmerga dressed as Iraqi soldiers besieged Shengal
09:40 Özgüneş: This will be the century of national unity and freedom for the Kurds
25/11/2020
17:27 Women raise both their words and struggle against violence
17:25 Alternating hunger strike against isolation begins in prisons indefinitely
13:36 Journalist Elî: There have been Turkmen groups among the soldiers sent to Shengal
13:36 Sexist November 25th poster from the trustee
13:35 November 25 message from arrested women politicians
09:41 Our detained reporter Karataş taken to Erzurum
24/11/2020
16:57 Restriction of legal council for our reporter Karataş
16:26 ECHR ruled for violation in Ahmet Şık case
14:07 Police attack workers marching to Ankara
11:48 Attorneys of Öcalan submits new application to visit İmralı
11:22 Disciplinary punishment for prisoner speaking to MA about spreading Coronavirus in prison
11:09 Police raid on our Van office
10:46 Riham Hesen: Turkey wants to control Shengal through KDP
09:27 Shengal Democratic Autonomous Assembly: All forces be ready to defend Shengal
09:27 Our reporter Dindar Karataş detained
09:26 JinNews editor Metina released
09:26 Five people jailed in DTK investigation in Diyarbakır
23/11/2020
16:28 HDP Immigration and Refugee Commission: We will be the voice of Iranian Z.N
15:27 Indictment for the rape in removal center prepared
15:10 Curfew declared in four neighborhoods in Mardin for military operation